Taste Test: Ranking the Best Frozen Deep Dish Pizzas for National Deep Dish Pizza Day

In honor of National Deep Dish Pizza Day, we conducted a thorough taste test of five different frozen deep dish pizzas available in local grocery stores. With prices ranging from $2.50 to $9.74, these pizzas were evaluated on key factors including crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings. Here’s how they ranked and which pizza emerged as the top contender.

First on our list was a personal-sized pizza priced at $2.50. While it offered a convenient option for a quick meal, the crust was notably thin and lacked the signature deep dish texture. The sauce was somewhat bland, and the cheese didn’t provide the gooeyness that deep dish lovers often crave. Overall, it scored low in our rankings.

Next, we tried a slightly more upscale frozen deep dish pizza priced at $4.99. This option had a thicker crust, which provided a satisfying crunch on the outside while remaining soft on the inside. The sauce was rich and flavorful, but it was a little too sweet for some testers. The cheese was adequately melted, and the toppings were generous, making it a strong contender.

The third pizza, priced at $6.99, stood out for its robust flavor profile. Its crust was perfectly crispy, and the sauce had a nice balance of acidity and sweetness. The cheese was plentiful and stretchy, making every bite enjoyable. Although some testers noted that the toppings could be more diverse, this pizza earned high marks for its overall taste and texture.

Coming in at fourth place was a premium option costing $9.74. While it boasted high-quality ingredients and a gourmet flair, the crust was thicker than expected, which made it a bit doughy. Although the sauce and cheese were both excellent, the overwhelming crust detracted from the overall experience. This pizza may appeal to those who prefer a heartier meal, but it wasn’t a favorite among our taste testers.

Finally, the winner of our taste test was a frozen deep dish pizza priced at $7.49. This pizza impressed with a perfectly baked crust that struck the right balance between crispy and soft. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, while the cheese melted beautifully into a gooey layer on top. Generous toppings added to the overall satisfaction, making it a well-rounded choice for anyone celebrating National Deep Dish Pizza Day.

As Ohioans gear up to enjoy this delicious day, our ranking highlights that while there are plenty of options for frozen deep dish pizza, the $7.49 option truly stands out. Whether you’re hosting a gathering or enjoying a quiet night in, this pizza is sure to satisfy your deep dish cravings.